Major shortcomings in the guidance and practice regarding the distinction between single and composite supplies

NEWS Published

VAT SWEDEN Should a toy enclosed in the supply of a meal be taxed separately at a 25 % VAT rate or should it be deemed ancillary to the supplied meal and be taxed at the 12 % VAT rate for food? Should the supply of a spare part used in a repair be treated as a separate supply of a good or as ancillary to the repair service? Is the lunch served as a part of a conference arrangement to be taxed at the 12 % reduced VAT rate for food or at the 25 % standard VAT rate as for the conference arrangement?

VAT is often considered one of the most complex and burdensome taxes for business to deal with. Over the years, the VAT system has grown increasingly difficult to understand and to handle for business as well as tax authorities and courts. One of the most complex issues is how to assess transactions consisting of several elements. For the purpose of VAT, one must determine whether a transaction consisting of several elements is to be deemed one single supply or two or more distinct supplies.

Although this is one of the most important issues concerning VAT, neither the Swedish VAT Act nor the VAT Directive provides any guiding provisions in this respect. Instead, business is dependent on guidance from the Swedish Tax Agency and the courts.

Anna Sandberg Nilsson and Hussein Abdali at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise have made a survey of the large number of statements and references found in the Tax Agency’s VAT Manual for 2012 in respect of the distinction between single and composite supplies. The survey show a lack of coherence in the guidance and practice, and the outcome can seem more or less random. Furthermore, the survey shows insufficient reasoning in the assessments, diverse treatment for different industries, different treatment for similar transactions and references to obsolete case law.

Moreover, Ernst & Young have, on behalf of the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise, studied the treatment of single or composite supplies in Europe. In summary, the survey shows that no general and uniform practise regarding the treatment of single or composite supplies exist within the EU, Norway or Switzerland. Numerous countries have no or very little national legislation, guidance or case law in this regard. Countries with an established and general guidance often build there legislation on principles established by the EU case law. Several countries apply an assessment based on percentage of the price.

The major shortcomings in the Swedish practice undermine fundamental legal principles, such as fiscal neutrality and equal treatment, and add to the already high material and administrative burden that VAT system entails. Urgent measures to deal with these shortcomings are thus needed. Furthermore, the diversity in treatment between countries in Europe may result in double taxation or double non taxation. This lead us to believe that there may be reason to revise the VAT Directive with regard to the treatment of supplies consisting of several elements in order to reach a more uniform practice.

• Letter to the Swedish Tax Agency regarding the Treatment of Single or Composite Supplies

o Annex 1 Survey: VAT Treatment of Single or Composite Supplies in the Swedish Tax Agency’s Manual, 2012 (available in Swedish only)

o Annex 2 E&Y Pan-European Survey: Questionnaire - VAT treatment of composite supplies

o Annex 3 Ernst & Young Pan-European Survey: VAT treatment of composite supplies

















News

NEWS Published:

11 exciting climate projects from Sweden

Swedish companies have long been at the forefront of combining sustainability and environmental ambitions with growth and innovation. From fossil-free steel to CO2 capture, Sweden’s businesses are leveraging tomorrow's technology for a greener world. As innovation and climate-smart solutions become an increasingly important element in our competitiveness, we have listed 11 ground-breaking climate projects currently underway in Sweden’s business world.
NEWS Published:

"There are no long term winners in a protectionist world"

EU Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General International and EU Affairs, believes that the new European Commission must demonstrate that it can manage several issues simultaneously. “It must keep the Union and the single market together, stand up for free movement and maintain its focus on core areas.”
NEWS Published:

Swedish Enterprise about the Green Deal

EU – There are several elements contained in the initiative that will be important for Swedish industry, says Lina Håkansdotter, Head of Sustainability and Infrastructure.
NEWS Published:

Worries over Brussels minimum wage initiative

EU The Swedish Labour Market Council for EU Affairs has sent a letter to Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission. The letter contains several sharp messages to the Commission, where one is that EU lacks competence in the area of pay. 
NEWS Published:

Stellinger on Trade Policy Day: "Protectionism means everyone loses"

INTERNATIONEL TRADE What is the way forward for EU trade policy during these turbulent times? This was the central issue during the European Parliament’s discussions on trade policy. "We live in an entirely new trade world" said Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General, international and EU affairs.
NEWS Published:

The GDPR alone is insufficient

GDPR The GDPR compromise from 2016 has been shown to have both strengths and weaknesses - particularly from a business perspective. It is vitally important to delivering proper data protection and trust, but it is demanding and costly to adhere to vague and overly-detailed legislation. This creates compelling reasons to discuss how to support compliance and important processing in order to remain technological competitive, says lawyer Carolina Brånby at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise. The report, entitled “What’s wrong with GDPR?”, is now available in English.
NEWS Published:

Questions vital for the future of the industry

SEMINAR The Swedish Construction Federation and MEP Abir Al-Sahlani (RE) have organised a seminar "Building Europe - Future of work the construction” in the European Parliament.
NEWS Published:

Anna Stellinger: Director of International and EU Affairs at Confederation of Swedish Enterprise

NEW LINE OF WORK Anna Stellinger today takes up the newly created position of Director of International and EU Affairs at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise. She will also join the management team.
NEWS Published:

Review the Swedish Exemption Regarding Financial Transactions

TAX The VAT exemption regarding financial transactions is often used in Sweden as an argument to raise taxes in the financial sector. However, the exemption is harming the business climate as well as growth and development.
NEWS Published:

EU lose much of its attraction without the single market

EU A fully developed single market is central to fight climate change, promote sustainable development, to fully harness the potential of digitalisation and strengthen Europe’s competitiveness. Without the single market, the EU would lose much of its attraction.
NEWS Published:

Proposals for competitiveness

REPORT The Confederation of Swedish Enterprise, in co-operation with its experts and membership organizations, has produced concrete proposals for measures to ensure that Europe will maintain its competitiveness in the global arena.
NEWS Published:

How EU-decisions affect Swedish companies

REPORT The Confederation of Swedish Enterprise has evaluated how the major decisions taken within the EU during the last mandate period affect Swedish companies. Our evaluation shows that 24 of the 57 legal acts we have chosen to look at have been positive for Swedish companies.
NEWS Published:

SME-companies in the digital economy

EU 24 million small and mid-sized businesses are the greatest asset within EU. "Regulations must be dealt with to give SME-companies the opportunity to reach their full potential", says  Anna-Lena Bohm, chairman of BusinessEuropes SME:s and Entrepreneurship committee.
NEWS Published:

SME-companies in the digital economy

BUSINESS There are 24 million small and mid-sized businesses, so called SME businesses, in Europe. These companies are a great – if not the greatest – asset when it comes to tackling todays economical and social challenges.
NEWS Published:

The Nordic countries need to block EU assault on tax veto

TAX For countries with a common currency and a limited common budget, it is particularly important to be able to pursue an active national fiscal policy when an external shock is encountered, writes Claes Hammarstedt.
NEWS Published:

Artificial intelligence on everybody’s mind

EVENT Artificial intelligence is on everybody’s mind in the EU capital. The European Commission recently launched its strategy for artificial intelligence, which focuses on promoting research and development of AI across European sectors.
NEWS Published:

AI made in EU

JOINT EFFORT The EU-commission has presented a joint effort with Member States to promote the development and use of artificial intelligence, AI, in Europe. To strengthen AI-technology and uptake in Europe is welcome. Swedish Enterprise believes that the conditions within Europe must be strengthened in order to successfully improve the global competitiveness of our companies. Here are our thoughts and proposals.
NEWS Published:

Swedish expert represents European industry in expert group on AI

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE The Confederation of Swedish Enterprise’s digital expert Carolina Brånby is representing BusinessEurope in the European Commission High Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence, AI HLEG. Their role is drafting ethical guidelines, and to create recommendations on how to strengthen the uptake of AI within the EU.
NEWS Published:

What impact of the Social Pillar on EU prosperity?

The EU’s approach to social policy is currently changing. In November 2017, the European Pillar of Social Rights (the Social Pillar) was proclaimed as a visionary document setting up goals for an upward convergence in this area. In this year’s State of Union address, the president of the EU-commission Jean-Claude Juncker asserted that “It is time we turned the good intentions that we proclaimed at the Gothenburg Social Summit into law”. And, as a matter of fact, this process is well under way.
NEWS Published:

The entrepreneurial perspective is being neglected in the EU digitalisation process

The digital single market is a hot topic in the EU right now. Sweden has plenty of confidence when it comes to digitalisation, which does by its nature transcends all borders. The government’s overall goal is for Sweden to be best in the world at using the opportunities offered by digitalisation. But unfortunately the entrepreneurial perspective usually comes second when the European countries attempts to create a digital inner market.