What impact of the Social Pillar on EU prosperity?

NEWS Published

The EU’s approach to social policy is currently changing. In November 2017, the European Pillar of Social Rights (the Social Pillar) was proclaimed as a visionary document setting up goals for an upward convergence in this area. In this year’s State of Union address, the president of the EU-commission Jean-Claude Juncker asserted that “It is time we turned the good intentions that we proclaimed at the Gothenburg Social Summit into law”. And, as a matter of fact, this process is well under way.

Mr Jutte, Mr Karlsson, MEP Federley
Foto: J Hedström

The potential effect of this new development was the topic of a seminar held on Tuesday 16 October titled “What impact of the Social Pillar on EU prosperity?” Following the presentation of the the report “The European Social Pillar: A Threat to Welfare and Prosperity? by Professor Nils Karlson (Ratio Institute)”, a lively panel discussion was held by MEP Fredrick Federley (ALDE), and Jeroen Jutte, Head of the unit Employment and social governance at DG EMPL, with Dr. Gabriella Sebardt, Director Social Affairs at the Confederation Swedish Enterprise, acting as moderator. The event was hosted by the latter organisation in collaboration with the Society for Politics and Business (Sällskapet för Näringsliv och Politik – SPN).

Dr. Sebardt started the discussion by confirming that signs had been visible well before the Gothenburg Summit, prompting joint actions by the Swedish social partners.

Professor Karlson elaborated on the Social Pillar’s possible consequences for the direction in which the EU is heading. “The Social Pillar will not only affect member states’ unique welfare systems but will also change their labour market models”, Karlson said. Setting objectives at the EU level legitimises EU legislation, rendering the subsidiarity principle a tool for centralisation, he contended. In the short-term, this will damage specifically the Scandinavian and Anglo-Saxon labour market models but in the long-term, it will disfavour all member states, threatening both prosperity and welfare. Instead of a one-size-fits-all-policy, the EU should encourage reforms in member states with weak governance, fragile welfare states, and uncertain labour markets. Such institutional competition allows for innovation (and policy learning) as well as accountability, the latter being important to ward off populist EU-critical movements.

Mr. Jutte painted a more visionary picture of the Social Pillar. He emphasized the importance of European competiveness when confronted by demographic challenges, global actors, and digitalisation’s impact on the labour force. Faced by these challenges, the EU needs to keep its global role and to strengthen growth by creating a European social dimension. Furthermore, the Social Pillar will not only benefit all member states, but also create an advantage for Swedish companies wanting to establish themselves in an eastern member state. According to Jutte, some member states need the Social Pillar due to uncertainty in their labour markets. “It is a shared commitment”, Jutte said. This, according to Jutte, will not go against the Swedish model – that is just a “false contradiction”. On the contrary, the Social Pillar was inspired by the Nordic and Swedish systems, thus Sweden should be pleased to spread this vital model.

MEP Federley was strongly critical of the Social Pillar and pointed out the difference between “Europe as a super state”, as phrased by the leader of ALDE-group Verhofstadt, and “federalism” as it ought be with distinct levels of competence. Federley posed the question why the EU should present one universal solution for all the member states, when some states already have well-functioning labour markets. According to Federley, the EU should instead advice those member states that “don’t do their homework” and encourage them to adopt better labour market systems with, for instance, regulation by collective agreements. The Social Pillar will not only give the populist groups more ammunition according to Federley, but eventually also risk tearing the union apart.

The discussion also had lively input from the audience on how the Social Pillar will impact different actors within the EU. Historically, the EU has always had a social dimension with some conferred powers in the area of social policy. Yet recently, the proposed directives are becoming far more detailed, leading to questions about whether the Social Pillar could interfere too much with well-functioning national labour-market systems. This is the backdrop to the seminar and the reason for its topical question: what impact will this new development have on European prosperity going forward?

Aras Amin


NEWS Published:

A recovery plan for Europe after COVID-19

EU If companies are to be able to emerge from the crisis and continue to grow, we need to see an ambitious and coordinated recovery plan for the EU as early as possible, write Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General, and Anders Edholm, Head of EU-office.
NEWS Published:

Necessary actions to mitigate the Corona crisis

TRADE Swedish Enterprise has sent a position paper to EU-commissioners, Members of the European parliament and several others in order to bring the attention to the list of proposals you can find below.
NEWS Published:

EU state aid regulations can save companies and jobs

COMMENT To help Member States preserve companies and jobs during the current coronavirus crisis, the European Commission has rapidly relaxed EU state aid regulations. At the same time, it is important to safeguard equal conditions for both competition and free enterprise, writes competition and state aid expert Stefan Sagebro.
NEWS Published:

Coronavirus crisis: Seven trade actions that need to be taken now

COMMENT The coronavirus outbreak is placing unprecedented pressure on the EU and international trade. The goal should be to lay the foundations for the best possible conditions post-Corona that keeps as many companies – and jobs – viable. We have no time to wait, writes Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General Confederation of Swedish Enterprise
NEWS Published:

Information on coronavirus / COVID-19 for you as a business owner

CORONA (UPDATED REGULARLY) Due to the recent developments in the spread of the coronavirus, we have summarised the sources where you, as a business owner/operator entrepreneur, can find the latest information.
NEWS Published:

In times of crisis, barriers are not the answer

COMMENT EU must now take powerful measures in the field of trade policy. A constructive measure would be to completely remove import duties on necessary medical equipment, hand soap and disinfectants, imported from third countries, writes Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General International and EU Affairs.
NEWS Published:

EU industrial strategy: "Now the real work will begin"

COMMENT The European Commission has presented an industrial strategy. This will lay out the course for the coming five years. The strategy presented today is simply the starting point. Now the real work will begin, says Göran Grén, Director Head of Business Policy and Law Division at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise.
NEWS Published:

"Most important a trade agreement with the UK"

FREE TRADE How should the EU relate to major powers such as the US and China? How does the EU best approach the defence of free trade and an open and a favourable investment climate? To find what our Swedish MEPs in the Trade Committee think, we asked Jörgen Warborn (M, EPP) a few questions.
NEWS Published:

"The US and China are blending trade policy with geopolitical goals"

FREE TRADE How should the EU relate to major powers such as the US and China? How does the EU best approach the defence of free trade and an open and a favourable investment climate? To find what our Swedish MEPs in the Trade Committee think, we asked Karin Karlsbro, L, Renew Europe.
NEWS Published:

This is how to shape Europe's digital future

COMMENT The European Commission is launching its strategy for Europe's digital future. “The debate on the surveillance society, the mapping of citizens and the profiling of consumers is an important consideration as we move into this future, writes lawyer Carolina Brånby.
NEWS Published:

A Competitive European Industry

EU The European Commission will present its industrial strategy on 10 March. In response to this, Swedish Enterprise has produced the position paper, "A Competitive European Industry". This summarises the organisation's views on a range of issues.
NEWS Published:

11 exciting climate projects from Sweden

Swedish companies have long been at the forefront of combining sustainability and environmental ambitions with growth and innovation. From fossil-free steel to CO2 capture, Sweden’s businesses are leveraging tomorrow's technology for a greener world. As innovation and climate-smart solutions become an increasingly important element in our competitiveness, we have listed 11 ground-breaking climate projects currently underway in Sweden’s business world.
NEWS Published:

"There are no long term winners in a protectionist world"

EU Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General International and EU Affairs, believes that the new European Commission must demonstrate that it can manage several issues simultaneously. “It must keep the Union and the single market together, stand up for free movement and maintain its focus on core areas.”
NEWS Published:

Swedish Enterprise about the Green Deal

EU – There are several elements contained in the initiative that will be important for Swedish industry, says Lina Håkansdotter, Head of Sustainability and Infrastructure.
NEWS Published:

Worries over Brussels minimum wage initiative

EU The Swedish Labour Market Council for EU Affairs has sent a letter to Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission. The letter contains several sharp messages to the Commission, where one is that EU lacks competence in the area of pay. 
NEWS Published:

Stellinger on Trade Policy Day: "Protectionism means everyone loses"

INTERNATIONEL TRADE What is the way forward for EU trade policy during these turbulent times? This was the central issue during the European Parliament’s discussions on trade policy. "We live in an entirely new trade world" said Anna Stellinger, Deputy Director General, international and EU affairs.
NEWS Published:

The GDPR alone is insufficient

GDPR The GDPR compromise from 2016 has been shown to have both strengths and weaknesses - particularly from a business perspective. It is vitally important to delivering proper data protection and trust, but it is demanding and costly to adhere to vague and overly-detailed legislation. This creates compelling reasons to discuss how to support compliance and important processing in order to remain technological competitive, says lawyer Carolina Brånby at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise. The report, entitled “What’s wrong with GDPR?”, is now available in English.
NEWS Published:

Questions vital for the future of the industry

SEMINAR The Swedish Construction Federation and MEP Abir Al-Sahlani (RE) have organised a seminar "Building Europe - Future of work the construction” in the European Parliament.
NEWS Published:

Anna Stellinger: Director of International and EU Affairs at Confederation of Swedish Enterprise

NEW LINE OF WORK Anna Stellinger today takes up the newly created position of Director of International and EU Affairs at the Confederation of Swedish Enterprise. She will also join the management team.
NEWS Published:

Review the Swedish Exemption Regarding Financial Transactions

TAX The VAT exemption regarding financial transactions is often used in Sweden as an argument to raise taxes in the financial sector. However, the exemption is harming the business climate as well as growth and development.